Nerve Injuries Can Be Hard to See, but Medical Tests, Doctors, and the Right Evidence Can Prove What Construction Workers Are Living With
Proving nerve damage after a NYC construction accident takes more than telling an insurance company about the pain. It takes medical testing, a clear link between the injury and the accident, and evidence showing how the damage affects a worker's ability to do their job and live their life. Without that proof, a serious injury can be brushed off as minor.
Insurers often fight nerve injury claims because the damage doesn't show up on a simple X-ray. They may call the symptoms exaggerated, blame them on old wear and tear, or point to years of heavy labor as the real cause. Those arguments can shrink the value of a claim or stop it cold.
A construction accident lawyer can work with doctors and gather the evidence needed to show the true impact of a nerve injury and push back against those arguments. That includes test results, treatment records, and accounts from the people who saw how the injury changed a worker's life on and off the job.
|
Signs Your Construction Injury May Involve Nerve Damage
|
How Construction Accidents Cause Nerve Damage
Construction sites put workers at risk of injuries that can damage nerves instantly or over time. NYC job sites, with their tall buildings and heavy equipment, are especially dangerous. Some of the most common causes of nerve damage include:
- Falls from Scaffolds and Ladders: A hard landing can herniate discs in the spine and compress the nerve roots that run to the arms and legs.
- Falling Objects: Tools, materials, and debris striking the head, neck, or shoulders can injure the spinal cord or the nerves near the shoulder.
- Crush Injuries: Heavy equipment, collapsing walls, and shifting loads can crush hands, arms, and legs, damaging the nerves inside.
- Electrocution: Contact with live wires can burn nerves and cause lasting numbness, weakness, and pain.
- Deep Cuts: Saws, grinders, and other power tools can sever nerves in the hands and arms.
- Repetitive Vibration: Years of using jackhammers, drills, and grinders can damage nerves in the hands and fingers.
Nerve damage often comes with other serious injuries, such as broken bones, spinal injuries, and head trauma. Because the nerve symptoms can be overshadowed by more obvious injuries at first, they may not be diagnosed right away. That delay is one of the reasons these claims need careful attention from the start.
Common Types of Nerve Injuries on Construction Sites
One of the most common construction nerve injuries is a pinched nerve caused by a herniated disc in the neck or lower back. Doctors call this radiculopathy, which simply means pain, numbness, or weakness that travels along a nerve. When it affects the lower back, it's often called sciatica, with pain shooting down the leg.
Other workers suffer injuries to the brachial plexus, a network of nerves near the shoulder that controls the arm and hand. Falls and blows to the shoulder can stretch or tear these nerves. Some workers also develop complex regional pain syndrome, or CRPS, a chronic condition that causes severe burning pain and swelling, sometimes after an injury that seemed minor at first.
Some nerve injuries heal with time, therapy, or surgery. Others are permanent and leave workers with lifelong pain, weakness, or loss of feeling. Whether the damage is temporary or permanent makes a huge difference in the value of a claim. That's why getting the right medical opinions about the long-term outlook is so important.
Medical Tests That Prove Nerve Damage
Nerve damage can't usually be seen on an X-ray, but other tests can prove it. An electromyography test, or EMG, measures how well muscles respond to nerve signals. A nerve conduction study measures how fast and how strongly signals travel through the nerves. Together, these tests can show exactly which nerves are damaged and how badly.
MRIs are another key tool. They can show herniated discs pressing on nerve roots or damage to the spinal cord. A neurologist's exam can also document problems with reflexes, muscle strength, and feeling in the arms, legs, hands, and feet. Those findings give an injury claim objective proof that's hard for an insurer to dismiss.
Timing matters. Workers who get tested soon after their symptoms start and keep up with follow-up visits build a much stronger record. Insurance companies treat any gap in treatment as an excuse to argue the injury wasn't serious or came from something else, even when the gap had a good reason, like a long wait for a specialist or trouble getting time off work.
| Type of Evidence | What It Shows | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|
| EMG and nerve conduction study | Which nerves are damaged and how severely | Gives objective proof of an injury insurers call subjective |
| MRI | Herniated discs and pressure on nerve roots or the spinal cord | Shows the physical cause of the nerve symptoms |
| Neurologist's or specialist's records | Changes in reflexes, strength, and sensation over time | Documents how the injury progresses and responds to treatment |
| Treating doctor's opinion | Whether the accident caused the injury and if it's permanent | Connects the damage to the accident and supports future care costs |
| Symptom journal | Daily pain, numbness, and limits on activities | Shows how the injury affects everyday life |
| Coworker and family testimony | Changes in the worker's abilities before and after the accident | Backs up the worker's account with outside observations |
Connecting the Nerve Damage to the Accident
Proving nerve damage exists is only part of the battle. A worker also has to show the construction accident caused it. Insurance companies often argue that a herniated disc or pinched nerve came from aging, degeneration, or an old injury. Those arguments are especially common for workers who've spent years doing heavy physical labor.
New York law doesn't let insurers off the hook just because a worker had an existing condition. When an accident makes an old problem worse, the injured worker can still recover compensation for that harm. Accident reports, photos of the job site, medical records from before and after the accident, and a doctor's opinion about the cause all help prove the connection.
Workers should also be ready for an independent medical exam, or IME. Despite the name, this exam is usually arranged by the insurance company, and the doctor isn't the worker's own physician. IME reports often downplay injuries or blame them on other causes. A lawyer can prepare a worker for the exam and challenge an unfair report with evidence from treating doctors.
Who Can Be Held Responsible Beyond Workers' Comp
Most injured construction workers can get workers' compensation benefits, which pay medical bills and part of lost wages. But workers' comp doesn't pay for pain and suffering, and it usually won't fully cover the long-term cost of permanent nerve damage. For many workers, that leaves a major gap.
New York's Labor Law can help fill that gap. Labor Law Section 240(1), often called the Scaffold Law, holds property owners and contractors responsible when workers are hurt in falls or by falling objects because proper safety equipment wasn't provided. Labor Law Section 241(6) covers injuries caused by violations of specific state construction safety rules.
Labor Law claims and other third-party claims are brought against parties other than the worker's employer, such as building owners, general contractors, and equipment manufacturers. A successful claim can cover pain and suffering, full lost wages, and future medical care, which matters most when nerve damage is permanent. Workers' immigration status doesn't stop them from pursuing these claims in New York.
A Scaffold Fall Shows How a Nerve Injury Claim Takes Shape
Imagine a carpenter working on a Midtown renovation when an unsecured scaffold plank shifts under his feet. He falls about eight feet and lands on his back. At first, he feels sore but goes back to work a few days later. Within weeks, he develops shooting pain and numbness down his left leg and struggles to stand through a full shift.
When he files a claim, the insurer sends him to its own doctor, who says the problem is old wear and tear in his spine. The insurance company argues his symptoms have nothing to do with the fall and offers him nothing beyond workers' comp. Without help, he could end up paying for years of treatment himself.
With a lawyer, the evidence tells a different story. An MRI shows a herniated disc pressing on a nerve root. An EMG confirms the nerve damage. His neurologist links the injury to the fall, and coworkers confirm he had no back problems before. The missing scaffold safeguards can also support a Labor Law claim against the owner and general contractor.
Steps to Protect a Nerve Injury Claim
The steps a worker takes after a construction accident can make or break a nerve injury claim. These actions help protect both their health and their right to full compensation:
- Report the Accident in Writing: A written report to the employer creates a record of when and how the injury happened.
- Get Medical Care Right Away: Describe every symptom, including numbness, tingling, and weakness, even if it seems minor.
- Follow Through With Specialists and Tests: Keep every appointment with neurologists and other specialists, and complete recommended testing.
- Keep a Symptom Journal: Write down pain levels, numbness, and the tasks that have become hard to do.
- Save Photos of the Job Site: Pictures of scaffolds, ladders, equipment, and missing safety gear can prove what went wrong.
- Get Coworker Names: Coworkers who saw the accident can confirm what happened.
- Avoid Recorded Statements: Don't give recorded statements to insurance companies before talking to a lawyer.
Under CPLR 214, New York generally allows three years to file a personal injury lawsuit, but evidence on construction sites can disappear much faster as equipment is moved and work moves forward. A lawyer can preserve that evidence, line up the right doctors, and make sure every responsible party is held accountable before key deadlines pass.
Building Nerve Injury Cases Insurers Can't Ignore
Nerve damage can change a construction worker's life, making it hard to work, sleep, or enjoy the things that matter most. Insurance companies know these injuries are hard to see, and they count on workers not having the evidence to prove them. Injured workers deserve a legal team that builds a case the insurer can't ignore.
Senior partner Pat James Crispi leads our team at Keogh Crispi, P.C., and he has spent decades in the courtroom, with hundreds of successful trials in negligence cases. We prepare every case for trial, and we won't be outworked or outmaneuvered by the insurance company. Our results include a $6 million recovery for construction workers hurt in a crane accident and a $5 million recovery for a security guard who suffered a brain injury when an unsecured wall section fell on him during a store renovation.
We handle construction accident cases on a contingency fee, so there's no fee unless we recover money for you. With offices in Manhattan and Nyack, we work with you, not just for you. Schedule a free consultation to learn more about your legal rights and options after a construction accident.
"Pat was very transparent and responsive to any of my questions or concerns throughout the whole process. He is very professional with his work & I would highly recommend." — Salvatore G., ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐