Personal Injury Lawyers New York, NY
212-818-0600
212-818-0600

Losing Vision in One Eye After a NYC Construction Accident

Construction worker wearing a hard hat and an eye bandage sits on a bucket beside scaffolding at a New York City job site.

Workers' Comp Pays a Fixed Award for the Eye, While a Labor Law Claim Can Cover Everything Else

Eye injuries on New York City construction sites can end a career in a single moment, and the law splits the path to recovery into two separate systems. Workers' compensation pays a fixed award set by statute, while a lawsuit against the property owner or general contractor can reach losses comp never touches. A serious eye injury on a job site often supports both kinds of construction accident claims, and early choices shape how much of the loss gets covered.

New York sets specific eye protection rules for construction work, and the state's Industrial Code requires approved eyewear suited to the hazard that is both provided and actually used. When owners and contractors fall short, Labor Law 241(6) can cover pain and suffering and full lost earnings. Attorney Pat James Crispi has tried hundreds of negligence cases, including construction claims built on Industrial Code violations.

The value of a one-eye injury goes well beyond the eye itself. Depth perception, future eye care, and limits on driving or running equipment all belong in the claim. Each one needs medical proof tied to the work the injured person can no longer do safely. Those details often decide whether a settlement reflects the real cost of the injury.

At a Glance

  • One Eye Equals 160 Weeks – New York's comp schedule values the total loss of one eye at 160 weeks of benefits, and losing 80 percent of the vision counts as total loss.
  • Glasses Don't Reduce the Award – New York uses corrected or uncorrected vision loss, whichever is greater, so corrective lenses can't shrink a schedule loss of use (SLU) award.
  • Contractors Must Enforce Eye Protection – Industrial Code section 23-1.8(a) requires approved eye protection to be provided and used, and owners and general contractors carry that duty.
  • A Lawsuit Covers What Comp Can't – Pain and suffering, full lost earnings, and the cost of losing depth perception are available only through a third-party claim.

How Does Workers' Comp Pay for Losing Sight in One Eye?

Workers' comp pays two kinds of money after a serious eye injury. Weekly benefits replace two-thirds of the average weekly wage while the worker can't work, up to a state cap. The New York State Workers' Compensation Board set that cap at $1,281.50 a week. It applies to injuries from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027. Once the eye stops improving, a permanent award follows.

That permanent payment is the SLU award. Under Workers' Compensation Law Section 15, one eye is worth 160 weeks of benefits. Losing 80 percent or more of the vision, or losing binocular vision, counts as a total loss. The Board uses corrected or uncorrected vision loss, whichever is greater. Glasses or contact lenses can't shrink the award.

At the 2026 cap, total loss of one eye works out to about $205,040. Extra weeks get added when total disability lasts longer than 20 weeks. Serious facial disfigurement can bring up to $20,000 more. Even so, comp pays nothing for pain and suffering. The rules for work injury claims also generally bar suing the employer directly.

New York's Eye Protection Rule for Construction Sites

Industrial Code section 23-1.8(a) requires approved eye protection suitable for the hazard involved. It covers welding, burning, cutting, chipping, and grinding, plus any other operation that may endanger the eyes. Courts have applied it to nail gun work. In Montenegro v P12, LLC, the Second Department, a New York appeals court, reinstated a worker's claim that he wasn't given adequate eye protection.

Labor Law 241(6) places this duty on owners and general contractors, and they can't hand it off. The rule also says protection must actually be used. In Sheley v Kingsfort Builders, Inc., the Fourth Department said contractors must make sure workers actually use the gear. Keeping goggles somewhere on site isn't enough.

That standard carries real weight in court. In Castellon v 38 E. 85th St., Inc., a 2025 case, the Second Department found the defendants responsible before trial. The Labor Law 241(6) violations included failing to provide adequate eye protection and to ensure it was used. Rulings like that let a case move from fault to the question of fair compensation.

Who Can Be Sued When Your Employer Is Off Limits?

New York generally doesn't allow a lawsuit against the direct employer, so the claim targets other companies. A third-party claim can name the property owner, the general contractor, or a construction manager. It can also reach another subcontractor whose crew created the hazard. The maker of a defective tool, such as a grinder sold without a proper guard, may share responsibility too.

Comp and a lawsuit can move forward at the same time, though their deadlines differ. Comp requires written notice to the employer within 30 days. The claim itself must reach the Board within two years, according to its claim fact sheet. A lawsuit generally must be filed within three years. Much shorter notice deadlines apply when a city or other public agency owns the site.

Comp and a Third-Party Lawsuit, Side by Side

The two claims pay for very different things, which is why an eye injury case usually needs both. Comp moves faster and doesn't require proof of fault. A lawsuit takes longer but reaches the losses comp leaves behind. Here's how they compare for a worker hurt on or after July 1, 2026.

Issue Workers' Comp Third-Party Lawsuit
Who Pays The employer's comp insurance company The owner's, contractor's, or other company's insurance company
Proof of Fault Not required A Labor Law violation or negligence
Pain and Suffering Not covered Covered
Lost Earnings Two-thirds of wages, up to $1,281.50 a week Full past and future lost earnings
Loss of the Eye Up to 160 weeks of benefits Based on the full impact on work and life
Deadline Notice in 30 days, claim within two years Generally three years

The comp insurance company doesn't walk away when a lawsuit succeeds. Under Workers' Compensation Law Section 29, it holds a lien (a legal right to repayment) on the recovery for benefits already paid. It can also claim a credit against future benefits. Settling the lawsuit generally requires its written consent or a court's approval. Skipping that step can cut off future comp benefits entirely.

What Should a One-Eye Vision Loss Claim Include?

Insurance companies often value a one-eye injury by the percentage of sight lost and little else. A complete claim documents how the injury changes health, work, and daily life for years to come.

  • Future Eye Care and Surgery – Glaucoma can develop years after eye trauma, according to the American Academy of Ophthalmology, so regular exams and possible surgery belong in the claim.
  • Loss of Depth Perception – One working eye makes it harder to judge distance on ladders, scaffolds, and stairs, or while guiding a load, which can end work in many trades.
  • Limits on Driving and Equipment – Federal rules let commercial drivers with one working eye qualify, but only after a specialist's evaluation, a road test, and yearly medical recertification.
  • Lost Earning Capacity – Union wages, overtime, and benefit contributions disappear when a worker can't return to the same trade, and the claim should measure that loss over a career.
  • Pain, Disfigurement, and Daily Life – Headaches, eye strain, light sensitivity, and changes in appearance affect everyday life, and workers' comp covers none of these losses.

Proving these losses takes more than a single eye exam. Treating specialists can document corrected and uncorrected vision, the visual field, and the long-term medical risks. Vocational and economic witnesses can then translate those limits into lost wages over a working life. Those measurements drive the SLU award on the comp side, too.

Evidence That Proves an Eye Protection Violation

Eye protection cases often turn on small details from the job site. Safety logs, toolbox talk records, and photos can show whether approved eyewear was available for the task. Coworkers can confirm what supervisors required and whether anyone checked for the right gear before cutting or grinding began.

That evidence fades quickly. Job sites change daily, crews move to other projects, and records get lost. A lawyer can send preservation letters to the owner and contractors. A lawyer can also lock down witness statements and the tool itself before memories fade or equipment gets repaired.

Trial-Ready Representation When Your Sight Is on the Line

Third-party insurance companies often claim eyewear was available or that the injury is smaller than it looks. Keogh Crispi, P.C. answers those arguments with evidence gathered early and a case built for a jury. We prepare every case for trial, and our case results include major recoveries tied to Labor Law 241 violations.

Our attorneys handle these cases on a contingency fee, so legal fees come out of a recovery, not your pocket. That lets injured workers focus on treatment while we take on the owner, the contractor, and their insurance companies. Both claims move faster when the evidence is secured from the start.

If a job site injury took vision from one eye, talk with our attorneys before the deadlines close in.

"[Pat Crispi] never backed down and refused to accept the insurance company's initial offerings. My final monetary recovery exceeded what the other side was offering by eight times." — Daryl B., ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Categories: Posts
New York City Office
Phone: 212 818 0600
FreeCase ConsultationClick Here